The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James
*contains spoilers*
In 1910, the literary critic Desmond MacCarthy wrote “Impressionism encouraged an artist to paint a tree as it appeared to him at the moment under particular circumstances”. Henry James, the painter of the portrait about which I’m writing now, was very much of the same mind when it came to literature. I was even more convinced on this on finding out that James asked for his own portrait to be painted by the noted Impressionist artist John Singer Sargent, as James himself appreciated the notion that his image was to be a personal interpretation of the artist’s mind as much as it was to be his own, corporeal, physical form. Somewhere in between the objective form and the artist’s interpretation lies an unreliability that is aptly reflected in the narrator of this beautiful piece of work’s delivery as he toys with the reader in both knowing perfectly and yet not being quite sure exactly how a character feels. In this way, James bridges the gap between Victorian Realism and Modernism in a wonderfully delicate manner by splitting The Portrait of a Lady into two definable but not overtly explicit styles: Realist and Gothic.
Isabel Archer is the lady in the portrait, and it is through her that James speaks of a many-varied issue. Isabel is visited in her lonely home in America by her aunt Touchett, and takes up her offer of being transported to Europe to experience and understand its culture, politics and history in a more concrete and empirical way. Only a few days after landing at the Touchetts’ beautiful property, Gardencourt, in England, however, the demands made by the men who are desperate to marry Isabel are already made, and they become suffocating; “’I don’t care a cent for your admiration – not one straw, with nothing to show for it. When will you marry me? That’s the only question.’” Boston’s capitalist, Caspar Goodwood, in love with Isabel before she even leaves America’s shores, travels over the Atlantic to cut short Isabel’s adventure to demand – not ask – for her hand in marriage. Another follows, pretty much immediately afterwards, by England’s aristocratic Lord Warburton – both of these men representing the extremes of their country’s economic and political systems – and at this point we just want all the suitors to leave poor Isabel alone. ‘Let her explore Europe’, I exclaimed at one point in the reading, ‘let her appreciate her individuality and all the cultural and historical wonders an adventure around Europe can afford her before she is to submit to married life forever’. Or something along those lines…
With all such decisions left hanging, James is constantly toying with the idea of what the true qualities of each of his characters are, how their actions conflict with their supposed natures, and whether outward signs indeed show any indication of what lies underneath; “Was the extremity of [Pansy’s] candour but the perfection of self-consciousness? Was it put on to please her father’s visitor, or was it the direct expression of an unspotted nature?” Our unreliable narrator comments on Isabel’s inner workings regarding Gilbert Osmond’s daughter as far as he can manage, and his suppositions become even less reliable as the novel proceeds. This uncertainty becomes infectious and thus becomes our own, and, three proposals in, we join Isabel in her ever-growing bad judgement of character. The narrator becomes less an abstract presence in the room of the novel’s goings-on and more a mere observer peering through a frosted window of one of the Old-World domiciles of Europe in which the many meetings take place, trying to catch a gesture here or there to make out what is really going on. With each passing page, and as more and more time is lost in between each chapter, we get a deeper sense also of Isabel’s agency falling away, until we learn that she has finally submitted to the very dubious Gilbert Osmond’s proposal. A few years into marital bliss she utters this sad lamentation; “’If I were afraid of my husband, that would be simply my duty. That’s what women are expected to be.’” Isabel begins the novel as a singular, confident, witty and intellectually ambitious force, and James, through Isabel, might be suggesting how women can become squashed and packaged by their more privileged halves in the confines of marriage. Where is the true Isabel now?
Countries, cities and buildings, especially in the more Gothic latter half of the text, hold great significances – Rome in particular comes to represent Isabel’s suffering in marriage with its long history of political machinations and deceit; “…in a world of ruins the ruin of her happiness seemed a less unnatural catastrophe…she had grown to think of it chiefly as the place where people had suffered.” Isabel is fooled by the much-too-charming Madame Merle, as are we readers, as she seeks to secure Osmond’s (and her daughter Pansy’s) future with Isabel’s inherited fortune. In the end, as Isabel’s future seems to be spinning out of her control, it also feels like something has escaped our grasp in the reading – but then something else even more important is acquired, too: agency. We only hope that beyond the pages Isabel can find hers also. How Impressionist of us all!
Comments
Post a Comment